Limited-time financing: 0% APR for 24 months on new HVAC system installs.Claim now
Boost Air And Plumbing logo, HVAC and plumbing in Arlington, TXBoost Air And Plumbing
AC repair in progress on a residential condenser by Boost Air And Plumbing

Boost Air Blog

Cracked Heat Exchanger: Repair or Replace the Furnace in Grand Prairie, TX?

Cracked heat exchanger: repair or replace? Call (817) 612-9107 or Book Online

Part of our Furnace Installation and Replacement guide.

Quick answer

Cracked heat exchanger furnace replacement is the usual path once a crack is confirmed. The exchanger keeps burner exhaust out of the air the blower sends through the house. Cracks are found by inspection, a camera, and carbon monoxide readings, not from the hallway. If an alarm sounds, get everyone out and call 911. If you smell gas, leave and call the gas company or 911 from outside.

If a carbon monoxide alarm sounds, get everyone out now, including pets. Do not look for the source, open windows and stay inside, or reset the alarm and keep the furnace running. From outside, call 911. Carbon monoxide has no smell. Headache, nausea, dizziness, confusion, or flu-like symptoms that ease outdoors are a reason to get out even if you have not found the alarm yet. If you smell gas, a rotten egg odor, leave. Do not flip switches, and do not use a phone inside. Call the gas company or 911 from outside. Keep working carbon monoxide alarms near the sleeping rooms, test them, and replace an alarm that is past the date on the back.

Cracked heat exchanger furnace replacement is the decision Grand Prairie homeowners face after someone has seen the exchanger, or after an alarm has already gone off with the heat on. The steps above are the whole job while an alarm is sounding or gas is in the house. The rest of this page is for after everyone is outside, or for a furnace that is already off.

The heat exchanger is not a sensor you can clean. Furnace repair is the visit that confirms what failed. Furnace installation is the replacement when the exchanger is finished. HVAC service in Grand Prairie is the local page. The Grand Prairie shop is at 2100 TX-360 Ste 907.

If the alarm is sounding now, follow the callout and the fire department. The longer alarm procedure, including a chirp versus a real alarm, is in carbon monoxide alarm when the furnace is on. This page stays on the exchanger.

What the heat exchanger does

A gas furnace burns fuel in a metal chamber. The heat of that flame warms the outside of the metal. The blower pushes house air across the outside of that metal and into the ducts. The exhaust from the flame is supposed to leave through the flue, never through the registers.

That metal is the heat exchanger. On a standard furnace it is a set of steel cells. On a high-efficiency furnace there is a second, tighter exchanger as well, because more heat is pulled from the exhaust before it leaves. Either way, the wall between flame and house air has to stay closed.

A crack, a hole, or a seam that has opened gives the exhaust a path into the airstream. The blower then sends that air through the rooms. Carbon monoxide can be in it. Carbon monoxide has no smell, so a furnace that seems to be heating is not proof the exchanger is intact.

How a crack is found

You cannot see this from the filter slot. Confirming a crack means the furnace is open, the burners and the blower are accessible, and someone is looking at the cells.

A visual inspection looks for rust-through, a separated seam, soot where house air and flame meet, and metal that has warped. Some cracks are obvious once the panels are off. Some are a hairline in a bend that a flashlight from the burner opening misses.

A camera, a borescope, goes into the cells so the inside of the metal can be seen. That is how a crack on the side facing the blower gets found when a look from the burner opening is not enough.

Carbon monoxide readings are the other check. A technician measures CO in the flue, where combustion products belong, and in the supply air, where they do not. A rise in the supply air when the blower starts is a reason the furnace stays off. Holding a household alarm at a register is not that test. Do not remove the burner cover, and do not run the furnace to see what the alarm does.

Signs that call for that inspection

These are reasons to shut the furnace off and have it checked. They are not a diagnosis you finish yourself.

  • A carbon monoxide alarm that sounds when the heat is on.
  • Headache, nausea, or dizziness that eases after you go outside.
  • Soot at the furnace, or soot at the supply registers.
  • A yellow or lazy flame you can see through the sight glass.
  • Rust flakes at the burner opening.
  • An exhaust smell in the house. Carbon monoxide itself has no smell. An exhaust odor is still a reason to leave the furnace off.

A furnace that starts and stops every few minutes can be a clogged filter or a weak blower. It can also mean the exchanger has been overheated for years. A new filter that does not stop the short cycling is a reason to inspect the exchanger. It is not, by itself, proof of a crack.

A light dusty smell on the first cold night, with no alarm and no symptoms, can be dust on metal that sat all summer. Grand Prairie furnaces often sit from spring until the first front. That smell should fade. It is a different problem from a crack.

Why a repair is rarely practical

The exchanger is the cabinet's core, not a part that unplugs. Replacing it means the gas, the vent, and the electrical connections come off, the furnace comes apart, and a cell that matches that exact model goes back in. Then the furnace is reassembled and combustion is checked again.

On many older models that cell is no longer made. A weld, furnace cement, or a patch is not a repair we put back in service. The metal expands every time the burners fire. A patch that looks closed on the bench does not make the wall intact.

Leave the furnace off while any of that is being decided. Running it until a part arrives keeps exhaust moving through the ducts. If you need heat in the meantime, use equipment rated for indoor use. A generator, a grill, or a fuel heater in the garage or the house makes carbon monoxide too.

A failed igniter, a coated flame sensor, or a capacitor on a furnace with a sound exchanger is still a repair. You should hear that price before the part is installed. The service fee is $0 when you approve the repair. A cracked exchanger is the finding that ends that kind of repair.

Warranty, in general

Many furnace makers cover the heat exchanger for longer than they cover the blower, the control board, and the igniter. That longer coverage is not automatic on your furnace. The paperwork that came with it, or the registration, is what applies. Some warranties stay with the house. Some stay with the original owner. Some exclude damage from overheating, a blocked filter, or a flue that was never right.

A warranty that pays for the part may still leave the labor. Labor on an attic furnace in Grand Prairie is a different job from labor on a closet furnace. A discontinued model can have a warranty and no part to send. A cabinet that is rusted through, or a metal flue with holes, is not fixed by a new cell.

Ask what the warranty pays on this furnace, and ask for a free replacement estimate beside any exchanger replacement that is still possible. Approve one of them before work starts. The furnace stays off until the new exchanger or the new furnace is in and combustion has been checked.

When a new furnace is the sensible choice

Replace the furnace when a crack is confirmed, when the exchanger for that model is not available, or when the cabinet or the flue is failing as metal at the same time. A younger furnace with one bad sensor and a closed exchanger is a repair, not this case.

The replacement quote should say how the furnace is sized, what happens to the vent, and whether the existing coil and air conditioner stay. An 80 percent furnace uses a metal flue. A condensing furnace needs plastic vents and a drain. Those details belong on the estimate. Signs a Grand Prairie furnace is finished is the wider list. This page is only the exchanger.

Replacement estimates are free. Financing as low as $99 a month is available on qualifying replacements. That figure is financing. The equipment price is in the written quote, because the final price depends on the system and the house.

The $29 furnace tune-up, through December 31, 2026, is a checkup for a furnace that is still safe to run. It is not the next step after a confirmed crack or a carbon monoxide alarm. Do not book a tune-up to put a cracked exchanger back in service.

Same-day service is available Monday through Friday. Hours are Monday through Saturday, 8am to 7pm. Call (817) 612-9107 or book online. Say if the furnace is already off, and if an alarm sounded.

Frequently asked questions

What does a furnace heat exchanger do?
It is the metal barrier between the burner flame and the air the blower sends through the house. Combustion gases stay on the flame side and go out the flue. House air stays on the other side and goes through the ducts. A crack lets combustion products into that airstream.
How is a cracked heat exchanger found?
A technician inspects it with the furnace open, often with a camera in the heat exchanger cells, and measures carbon monoxide in the supply air and the flue. A look from the hallway will not show it. Do not remove the burner cover to check.
Can a cracked heat exchanger be repaired?
Rarely in a way that belongs back in service. The exchanger is built into the cabinet. A weld or a sealant is not a dependable repair on metal that heats and cools every cycle. A replacement exchanger, when the exact part still exists, means pulling the furnace apart. On many older furnaces the practical path is a new furnace.
Does a heat exchanger warranty mean the furnace should be repaired?
A longer warranty on the exchanger is only one fact. Many makers cover the heat exchanger longer than they cover the blower, the board, and the igniter. Coverage still depends on the warranty for that furnace, whether it was registered, and what caused the crack. A covered part can still leave the labor, a discontinued model, or a rusted cabinet. The furnace stays off while that is checked. Ask for a free replacement estimate beside any repair that is still possible.
What should I do if a carbon monoxide alarm sounds or I smell gas?
If a carbon monoxide alarm sounds, get everyone out, including pets, and call 911 from outside. Do not reset the alarm and keep the furnace running. If you smell gas, a rotten egg odor, leave and call the gas company or 911 from outside. Do not flip switches or use a phone inside. Carbon monoxide has no smell.

Need a hand from a licensed tech?

Call (817) 612-9107 or book online. We serve Arlington, Grand Prairie, and the surrounding North Texas communities.

Visit our shops

Two DFW locations serving the entire Metroplex

Boost Air And Plumbing dispatches trucks from our Arlington main office and our Grand Prairie shop, covering Tarrant and Dallas counties with same-day HVAC and plumbing service. Call (817) 612-9107 for either location.

Arlington (Main Office)

Boost Air And PlumbingArlington, TX

  • 2313 Michigan Ct
    Arlington, TX 76016
  • (817) 612-9107
  • Monday to Saturday: 8:00 AM to 7:00 PM
Get directions

Grand Prairie

Boost Air And PlumbingGrand Prairie, TX

  • 2100 TX-360 Ste 907
    Grand Prairie, TX 75050
  • (817) 612-9107
  • Monday to Saturday: 8:00 AM to 7:00 PM
Get directions